In 2014, Louis Vuitton sued My Other Bag, a small Los Angeles company selling canvas totes for roughly $30 to $55. Louis Vuitton alleged that My Other Bag’s use of its designs constituted trademark infringement, diluting the value of the famous marks. One side of the tote says “My Other Bag…”, a nod to the old “my other car is a [Ferrari/BMW/Mercedes]” bumper sticker, with a cartoon drawing of a luxury handbag on the other side. Louis Vuitton also tried a narrower argument: that a parody defense should only apply if the joke targets that one exact brand, not luxury bag culture as a whole. Louis Vuitton pointed to a prior case requiring that a parody be specific to its brand rather than speak to luxury or consumption in general. The courts didn’t buy either argument. My Other Bag won, kept winning on appeal, and the case is still cited as the clean example of when a joke is obviously a joke.
That’s most of the argument for parody streetwear, decided in federal court instead of a group chat. The bit worth remembering: the joke doesn’t have to be about one company. It can be about the whole idea of paying a fortune for a symbol.